Peanut Butter Paprika Cookies - 6 pack - Thanksgiving 2026

• Once ordered, pre-orders cannot be changed to an earlier pick-up date or time. Please double check that all of your pre-order dates match prior to checking out.
• Once the pre-orders for a specific date or flavor have sold out, we cannot accommodate more pre-orders for that date/item. 
• All pre-orders must be picked up by 10:00am on Thursday 11/27. No refunds will be given for orders not picked up by that time.

At this time, online pre-orders can only be paid for by credit/debit card.

• Ingredients: all-purpose flour, unsalted butter, granulated sugar, light brown sugar, peanut butter (dry roasted unblanched peanuts), eggs, whole wheat flour, pure vanilla extract, kosher salt, baking powder, baking soda, ground smoked paprika, topped with flaky sea salt, turbinado (raw) sugar, and ground smoked paprika.
• Allergens: wheat, eggs, milk, peanuts. Made in a facility that uses tree nuts, soy, and sesame.
• General Allergen Statement: Sister Pie is a shared-equipment kitchen, meaning we do not have separate kitchen equipment (including ovens) that we use for products with common allergens. We keep our kitchen very clean and thoroughly wash and sanitize equipment, surfaces, and hands in-between use, and do our best to consider allergies when making our food products, however we cannot guarantee that there will be no risk of cross contamination as we are not an allergen-free bakery. Sister Pie aims to be as transparent as possible about our practices for the safety of our guests.